Native Plants
![](../_images/smarty_plants.gif)
Q. Who is Mr. Smarty Plants?
A: There are those who suspect Wildflower Center volunteers are the culpable and capable culprits. Yet, others think staff members play some, albeit small, role. You can torture us with your plant questions, but we will never reveal the Green Guru's secret identity.
Did you know you can access the Native Plant Information Network with your web-enabled smartphone?
Ask Mr. Smarty Plants is a free service provided by the staff and volunteers at the Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center.
![](../_images/mr_smarty_plants_logo_web_200w.jpg)
rate this answer
![](../_images/star_00.gif)
Wednesday - December 05, 2012
From: San Antonio, TX
Region: Southwest
Topic: Butterfly Gardens, Compost and Mulch
Title: Will recycled tire mulch harm butterfly larvae?
Answered by: Nan Hampton
QUESTION:
I discovered orange butterfly larva in the hardwood mulch under my Turk's Cap. Will it harm the larva if I switch over to recycled tire mulch?ANSWER:
Mr. Smarty Plants is very happy that you are thinking about the potential effects of your choice of mulch material on insect residents of your garden. Butterflies are beautiful and many other insects serve as pollinators in your garden. However, I am a little dubious that the larva you found in your mulch is a butterfly caterpillar. Butterflies lay their eggs on the host plants that their caterpillars will eat. The caterpillars are pretty much "eating machines" and munch away, growing until they have reached the size to pupate and form their chrysalis. They don't really spend time in mulch unless they accidentally fall to the ground or have eaten up their host plant and are searching for another. I suspect what you found in your mulch is the larva for a species of beetle. Many beetle larvae overwinter in the soil. Here are a few common species of mostly orange butterflies that you would find in Bexar County from the check list on the Butterflies and Moths of America webpage. You can see their larvae on each species page:
Agraulis vanillae (Gulf fritillary)
Dryas julia (Julia Heliconian)
Now, for the matter of using recycled tire mulch, there are several reasons NOT to use it for mulch in your garden.
- From Environment and Human Health, Inc., the tire crumbs have been found to contain "volatile organic hydrocarbons (VOCs) with carcinogenic potential" that have been documented in human health effects "ranging from severe skin, eye and respiratory irritation to three forms of cancer". These are released in gaseous form and also as leachates that can enter the ground water.
- The tire crumbs are black and absorb heat from the sun. You live in San Antonio where there is no lack of sun and heat in the summer. Why put a mulch over the roots of your plants that will increase the heat of the soil surrounding them?
- Whereas recycled tire mulch releases VOCs, organic mulches (e.g., bark, wood shavings, compost, etc.) eventually decompose and release compounds that provide nutrients to your plants, earthworms and beneficial soil organisms.
Aggie Horticulture has a very good article, Mulches for Enhanced, Low-cost, Low-maintenance Landscapes, that you might find helpful and you can also read an another excellent article, Mulches, from University of Missouri Extension. You might also want to read RUBBER MULCH–Beware from Nature's Way Resources.
More Butterfly Gardens Questions
Non-invasive plants for hummingbird and butterfly garden
January 20, 2009 - Hello :)
I've been building a huge Hummingbird and Butterfly garden. Up until now I've only had the Milkweeds and Dill for host plants for the Monarch and Black Swallowtail Butterflies. I'd love t...
view the full question and answer
Pollinators for Washington State
June 26, 2015 - Dear Mr. Smarty Plants,
I am removing invasive knotweed in the Pacific Northwest and I would like to provide native plant alternatives that would flower and provide pollen in the late summer/fall f...
view the full question and answer
Amending soil for butterfly garden in Houston
April 01, 2013 - My girl scout troop will be planting a butterfly garden at a middle school in Houston. In researching plants to use, we have come across some such as echinacea, rose vervain, galliarda and Texas gay...
view the full question and answer
Butterfly garden in Austin
May 28, 2008 - I am located in North Central Austin, and just bought a house with a large back yard. One half is shade-part sun, and the other half is full sun. The shade from three large (55-60) foot trees. I am...
view the full question and answer
Butterflies attracted by Pink Evening Primrose from Burnet TX
July 30, 2012 - I see information on Pink Evening Primrose that says it attracts 'many butterflies'
Please tell me which butterflies and name them? I've looked everywhere and am just exhausted and frustrated with...
view the full question and answer
Support the Wildflower Center by Donating Online or Becoming a Member today. |